Hippy's Happy Film Review

Saving Private Ryan




Details

US 1998 171m

Director

Steven Spielberg

Cast

Tom Hanks, Tom Sizemore, Edward Burns, Matt Damon, Jeremy Davies, Giovanni Ribisi



The mission is a man
Ours is not to question why ... This'll be a piece of p--s
Some guys and some guns Happy, smiley people


One thing that Hollywood loves is its war films; ever since they turned up to Save Europe they haven't stopped shouting about it, writing about it and making films about it.

Most American, World War Two films present the conflict as an American war steeped in glory and honour.

Whilst Spielberg continues to concentrate on American involvement, there is no way that this film can be said to glorify war or armed conflict.

The film opens with a half hour assault on one's senses as the Yanks land and take on Omaha Beach, D-Day, 6th of June. This is a depiction of war that is brutal and honest. It pulls no punches and it doesn't flinch from showing the true horror, the violence and the destruction of life.

The film has been criticised for traumatising its audience before the film gets underway; it is traumatising and, I was surprised how much so for a film that has been given a 15 certificate. However, as Peckinpah and Tarrantino have shown, the brutal realism of death, rather than sanitized, comic book, A-Team, violence, discourages rather than encourages emulation.

The story unfolds as we follow a small unit of eight soldiers searching for Private James Ryan, the last surviving brother of four, to return him home.

The flow sags a little in places but not so much that interest is lost and the pace picks up as they continue to track down their man.

The mission is accomplished, but Ryan won't leave his unit and return home.

The search unit teams up with Ryan's, to hold a bridge deep behind the lines, and the film, again, shows its brutally realistic approach as this objective is undertaken.

Saving Private Ryan is a film that portrays war for what it is, indiscriminate, pointless and painful, doesn't glorify war and manages to avoid moralising. The plot is credible and well executed and the characters are well developed and excellently portrayed.

I said in my review of Lock, Stock and Two Smoking Barrels that Hollywood couldn't do Gritty Films; I now have to admit that Spielberg knows how to. And knows how to do them well.

There are going to be more than a couple of Oscars going in its direction.


One of the local papers that I receive, Hertfordshire On Sunday, carried an advertisement for the film which consisted of a half page photograph from the opening battle scene and a two column inch review. The heading read, "Hanks and tanks", with a footer proclaiming, "It's muddy marvellous ...". Perhaps the reviewer went to see the Director's Comedy Cut ? Or maybe this is just another case of sensationalist, tabloid journalism that has now extended itself into film reviewing. Fubar.





Site Navigation

  Home Page
  What's New
  Film Reviews
  Search
  Add Bookmark
  Have Your Say
  Guestbook



Ratings



First published sometime before Tuesday the 7th of December, 1999
Last upload was on Tuesday the 10th of August, 2004 at 23:00:29