Hippy's Happy Film Review

Pleasantville




Details

US 1999 98m
Black and White / Colour

Director

Gary Ross

Cast

Tobey Maguire, Reese Witherspoon, Joan Allen, William H Macy, Jeff Daniels, J T Walsh




Not everything is black and white


Squabbling brother and sister, David and Jennifer, couldn't be more different; he's an anorak, obsessed by the 1950's TV show Pleasantville, she's a go get 'em girl. So when the 24 hour Pleasantville Marathon is pitted against Jennifer's big date; all hell is let lose.

In the ensuing fracas, the television remote control is destroyed, but a convenient, passing TV repairman gives them a replacement and, "Kapow", both find themselves in Pleasantville living the lives of Bud and Mary Sue in the black and white sitcom world.

The perfect, "Honey, I'm home", world is soon shattered as the predictability and monotony of the town is slowly destroyed by questions, which would never have been asked, and the revealing of knowledge, previously unknown.

As Pleasantville is slowly affected, the townsfolk begin to see things in a different light, experience new emotions and, quite literally, colour is brought to their lives and town.

But that's nothing more than the five minute thirty second trailer showed !

I must admit that I was quite apprehensive about seeing the film, having seen the trailer, I couldn't see what more there could be to this film and I was starting to suspect it would be little more than sentimental slush.

The trailer does indeed blow the whole plot away and whether you need to see the whole film, if you've seen the trailer, is debatable.

It's a great little film, excellently directed and the colourisation effects work extremely well ( definitely in line for the Academy Award for Artistic Direction and it should have been in the nominations for Best Visual Effects ) but was there more to this epic than the trailer had already disclosed ?

Well yes and no. The padding filled out the film nicely with some quite hilarious scenes and lines but it added very little of substance. The effects of people becoming coloured on those who weren't, and their consequential reactions, were more dramatically portrayed but I found the whole racist parallelism a little overdone; the, "No coloreds", references I found to be entirely patronising given that only the most comatose audience member could have failed to see the situation developing on screen without prompting.

The point of the film escaped me; it was all very pleasant, entertaining and certainly a lot better than I had given it credit for before viewing. Apart from the racial harmony issue though, that Pleasantville had burst into living colour; so what ?

It would be very pretentious to assume that the townsfolk were any happier in their brightly coloured world than they were before. As a comment upon unwanton interference in a happy society the film can be seen as a warning but that would seem to be against the spirit of the film and the views of other critics who proclaim it to be this year's feel good movie. Where the feel good element comes from I'm not sure.

Why the mysterious TV repairman turned up and what his purpose was, other than as a pretty weak plot device, was never really explained.

And the film ended before the, "What have you done with my daughter ?", line was uttered.

Pleasant and entertaining, thought provoking ? Not really. Scrutinise the film too deeply and it soon loses most of its magic.

It's still well worth seeing, there are a lot worse films to be found, and the rendition of Across The Universe during the closing credits is worth hanging on for.





Site Navigation

  Home Page
  What's New
  Film Reviews
  Search
  Add Bookmark
  Have Your Say
  Guestbook



Ratings



First published sometime before Tuesday the 7th of December, 1999
Last upload was on Tuesday the 10th of August, 2004 at 23:00:29